Does a Wagging Tail Mean a Happy Dog?

Black dog with tail held high

Zani’s tail is up, and you’ll see in the video below that it is wagging. Does she look friendly and happy?

Why do dogs wag their tails? The prevailing view is that they do so when they feel happy and friendly. Many do, but dogs also wag their tails in other situations. So the answer to the title question is no. Dogs wagging their tails are not always expressing friendliness or joy. Not by a long shot.

Many dogs will wag their tails from arousal or when performing predatory behaviors. Some will wag when they are getting ready to aggress. My dog Clara has a particular wag when she is anxious. When observing a dog wagging its tail, we need to look at the rest of the body language to determine what’s going on. Some things to look at are:

  • how the dog is moving and in what direction;
  • whether its movements are stiff or relaxed;
  • whether its mouth is tight or relaxed; and
  • whether the dog is looking directly at something (including you!).

An important factor is the carriage of the tail. How high is the tail? (See section below on breed differences.) Other important factors are whether the tail is wagging fast or slow and whether it is stiff or loose. These things can mean the difference between an eager greeting and an oncoming attack. We can never assume that a wagging tail means a dog is friendly.

The Direction of the Wag

There is scientific research that has found a correlation between the direction of a dog’s tail wag with its emotional state. It was found that the tail wagged predominantly to the right when the dog was responding to something it might want to approach, such as its owner. The tail wagged more to the left in response to something the dog would want to avoid. When you look at the video below, can you identify a sidedness to Zani’s tail wagging? Does it correlate with what we find at the end?

This research verifies what we can already see: dogs don’t wag their tails only to express happiness. They also wag their tails during general arousal, aggression, and other emotional states.

Tail Carriage

I haven’t found any research on the height of the tail when wagging, but experienced dog trainers learn to pay attention to that. In general terms, low and loose wags are usually friendlier than wags with the tail held high and stiff.

I think it’s hard to do research about that, though, because of big differences in “normal” tail carriage between breeds, not to mention between individual dogs.

Many northern breeds, like this Shiba Inu, have a naturally high tail carriage. Their tails are built that way.

Light brown shiba inu dog with tail curled up over its back (normal carriage)

Shiba Inu courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Rhodesian Ridgeback with tail hanging straight down

Rounder is feeling good but his tail is hanging straight down

On the other hand, some hound breeds have naturally low hanging or even tucked tails. Rounder the Rhodesian Ridgeback is in a good mood in this photo, but his tail is hanging straight down. You can find extreme examples of this in whippets and greyhounds, who often tuck their tails between their legs when standing. This tail carriage could mean “I am miserable or afraid” in many other dogs. For the whippet, it’s often just business as usual.

Summer is expressing predatory aggression in her stance, the set of her mouth, and the curl of her tail

 

 

 

 

 

My mixed breed dog Summer probably had some northern breeds in the mix. She held her tail at different heights depending on her mood and activities. She wasn’t all that waggy, but she had a beautiful, low, wide wag when she saw someone she loved. When her tail was tightly curled up over her back it always meant she was aroused, often predatory. In this photo, she was watching a cat on the other side of our fence.

Note the stiffness of her body, the slight lean forward, the set of her mouth, and the piloerection (hackling) around her shoulders.

Why Is This Dog Wagging Her Tail?

The video shows my dog Zani in my friend’s yard. The video shows a few seconds of her behavior. Her tail is wagging the whole time. It first plays with the sound off, so you can concentrate on her body language. Then it plays again with sound. Then finally you see the reason for her behavior. Is she wagging because she is friendly?

Link to the movie for email subscribers.

What Other Body Language Accompanies Zani’s Wagging Tail?

Watch the way Zani moves. Is she moving toward something, away from something, or both? Is she eagerly approaching something? Is she looking at something, listening to something? Look at the fur down the center of her back. Look at the set of her mouth.

You’ll have to watch the movie to see what Zani was responding to, and hear my own final conclusion of what was going on for her. One thing I haven’t mentioned yet: the whole sequence is adorable. Enjoy!

Related Pages and Posts

Photo Credits

Shiba Inu: Takashiba via Wikimedia Commons
Rounder the Ridgeback: Marge Rogers
All others: Eileen Anderson

Reference

Quaranta, A., Siniscalchi, M., & Vallortigara, G. (2007). Asymmetric tail-wagging responses by dogs to different emotive stimuli. Current Biology17(6), R199-R201.

Copyright 2018 Eileen Anderson

Share Button
This entry was posted in Dog body language, Human and dog misunderstandings and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Does a Wagging Tail Mean a Happy Dog?

  1. Monica Lord says:

    Is the wagging direction from facing the dog’ s head or her tail?

  2. Chris from Boise says:

    Zani’s tail was really whipping, but I’d say slightly more to the left, which matches her uneasiness and caution. Great video! And very wise mushroom to stay immobile faced with that kind of threat. Is Zani generally neophobic, or was this particularly exciting/unnerving because of the location: where small animals have been known to hang out?

    • Eileen Anderson says:

      Yes, the mushroom was very smart! She is not generally neophobic. I do have one other video of her acting very similarly though. It’s linked at the end of the post and it’s in the post called Intruder in the Yard. That time she got very wary because a landscape timber had rolled a couple feet out of its usual position. She’s normally easygoing though. I think in this case, her vision is deteriorating a bit and the mushroom was in the shadow under the shed. It just “looked weird.”

  3. Don Hanson says:

    Great post Eileen!

  4. Pingback: Shared Blog Post – Does a Wagging Tail Mean a Happy Dog? – Green Acres Kennel Shop Blog

  5. Maria says:

    Great article and great video! I particularly liked when you pointed out that breed differences can muddle the waters of interpreting tail-carriage body language.

    I think the tendency to equate a dog’s tail position & wag with a human smile is correct–but only if we remember that humans smile for many reasons other than happiness! A human “smile” can be a grimace of distaste, an aggressive baring of teeth, a nervous grin, or a warm and happy smile. So can a dog’s tail can express a huge range of emotions, which we can try to interpret using the rest of their body language.

    I’ve also seen dogs carry their tail down when they were training and have been asked if that didn’t mean that clicker training made them unhappy–after all, the dog’s tail was down! “Don’t you ever ‘frown’ when you’re concentrating?” I responded.

    People want dogs to be simple little robots, when their body language is as nuanced and complex as our own….

    • Eileen Anderson says:

      Excellent points. I’ve had to point out in more than one post that Zani actually tucks her tail all the way under when she is interacting with a food toy or even just eating out of a bowl. It took me some careful observation over time to decide she was fine! Just concentrating, as you mentioned. Glad for your comment–I need to link these two posts to each other!

Comments are closed.